InDesign vs SmartAlbums: Which Is Better for Album Design?

Short answer: InDesign gives you the most control over layout and typography, and SmartAlbums gets you to a finished album much faster. You don't have to pick one, though, because SmartAlbums can export to InDesign.

At a Glance

Why Designers Choose InDesign

1. Full creative freedom. You can place photos, text, shapes, masks and graphics anywhere, with no templates in the way.
2. Strong typography. For editorial-style albums, magazines and luxury books, InDesign controls fonts, spacing, character and paragraph styles, and text flow precisely.
3. Unusual layouts. A large hero image, small supporting images, story text, decorative elements and a custom grid are all possible.
4. One tool for many projects. You can use it for albums, photo books, magazines, lookbooks, brochures and portfolios.

The Cost of InDesign

InDesign makes you do more of the work. Take a wedding with 500 photos and an 80-page album:

Master pages, templates and scripts can shorten the InDesign process. Even so, you start from a blank page, and you're responsible for bleed and printer specs. It also costs more than SmartAlbums on a monthly plan, and album-specific features like proofing aren't built in.

Why Designers Choose SmartAlbums

• Speed. Make cuts in the timeline and layouts build themselves from handcrafted templates.
• Customisation. You can still adjust photos, frames, colours, fonts, text and backgrounds, and save your own templates.
• Print readiness. Album specs and print requirements are applied automatically, and the company offers a reprint guarantee for misprints caused by the software.
• Cloud Proofing. Clients comment on spreads from a browser flip-book (included in Plus).

Its weak spot is typography. If your albums rely on detailed text design, expect SmartAlbums to feel more limited than InDesign.

Using Both: The IDML Workflow

SmartAlbums exports fully layered PSD and IDML files, so you can:

1. Build the album quickly in SmartAlbums.
2. Export to IDML for InDesign, or to PSD for Photoshop.
3. Do advanced typography or retouching in Adobe.
4. Bring finished changes back, as SmartAlbums says Adobe edits can sync back to it.

This gives you speed on 90% of each album and full control on the spreads that need it.

Where AlbumMaker Fits

AlbumMaker aims for the same middle ground: automatic layouts you can keep editing.

• AI Magic Designer. Drop in photos and get draft layouts based on aspect ratios instantly.
• Canvas editing. Add text, shapes, adjust layers, custom fonts, typography, blend modes, and freely overlap elements just like InDesign.
• PSD export. Export fully layered PSDs for final finishing in Photoshop (IDML is not supported currently).
• Cloud Client Approval. Integrated flip-book proofing for client feedback. See how it works.

Note: While AlbumMaker provides extensive typography and freeform layering capabilities that surpass basic album builders, it does not aim to replace the massive publishing and multi-page text-flow tools found in InDesign. Photographers who rely heavily on complex editorial typography should test it out during the trial.

Which Should You Choose?

• InDesign if typography and unusual layouts are your signature, or you also design magazines and brochures.
• SmartAlbums if you do many albums a year and want speed, built-in print setup and proofing.
• Both if you want a fast first draft in SmartAlbums and detailed finishing in InDesign.
• AlbumMaker if you want a lighter, faster album-specific tool with a 14-day free Pro trial (no credit card required). Test it with a real album and check whether the editor covers your design needs.

Keep Reading